Canada’s ongoing dispute with India, fueled by allegations of Indian involvement in violent actions against Sikhs in Canada, has introduced concerns about intensified cyber threats and strained immigration processes. While these tensions have prompted widespread scrutiny, trade relations between the two countries appear largely unaffected, highlighting the complex layers of this diplomatic rift.

The tension escalated following comments made by a senior Canadian official in a parliamentary national security committee. The official alleged that India’s Home Affairs Minister Amit Shah, a key ally of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, orchestrated actions against Sikhs in Canada. Though Indian officials strongly deny these allegations, such statements have added to the diplomatic fallout that began when Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau revealed what he called “credible evidence” implicating Indian agents in the June 2023 assassination of Sikh leader Hardeep Singh Nijjar in British Columbia. The disclosure has strained relations, sparking cyber espionage concerns and affecting Canada’s immigration capabilities but leaving trade relations largely intact, for now.

Escalating Cybersecurity Concerns

Cybersecurity threats from India, previously considered an “emerging threat” by the Communications Security Establishment Canada (CSEC), are now under closer scrutiny. According to CSEC, India might intensify its cyber operations as a show of strength amid these diplomatic tensions. Caroline Xavier, CSEC’s head, remarked during a recent press conference that “as Canada and India potentially have some tensions, it is possible that we may see India want to flex those cyber threat actions against Canadians.” This implies that Canadian networks, including government and private sectors, may face increased threats, specifically in surveillance and intelligence gathering.

Historically, India has leveraged cyber operations in geopolitical conflicts, particularly in areas involving neighboring countries. While Canada has robust cybersecurity defenses, a concerted escalation from India could test these capabilities. Notably, cybersecurity is an area that can escalate swiftly and often quietly, posing significant risks to both government agencies and private enterprises.

Analysts have urged Canada to enhance its cyber defenses and maintain vigilance. Given the vast number of Indian nationals and students living in Canada, sensitive information and infrastructure are considered high-priority targets. Canadian agencies, however, are closely monitoring and preparing for any sudden changes in threat levels.

Impact on Immigration Processes

The diplomatic dispute has led to a substantial reduction in Canada’s immigration presence in India, causing delays in visa processing and backlogs. Immigration Minister Marc Miller indicated that only four Canadian immigration officials remain in India, down from 27 in October 2023. This limited workforce has impaired Canada’s ability to process visa applications on-site, affecting students, workers, and family reunification cases. “This could get worse before it gets better,” Miller warned, signaling potential delays for Indian nationals looking to study or work in Canada.

The strained immigration process comes at a time when Canada is increasingly reliant on international students and foreign workers to address its labor market needs. India is Canada’s largest source of international students and temporary workers, making the efficiency of the immigration process crucial for the nation’s economy and educational institutions. However, the uncertainty around this situation has led some educational institutions and businesses to consider alternative sources for international talent as a precautionary measure.

The fallout from this immigration slowdown could further strain Canada’s labor market, where sectors like healthcare, technology, and service industries rely heavily on foreign workers, many from India. This dependency on a steady flow of skilled labor from India may lead to increased pressure on the government to address the diplomatic rift more proactively.

The Unyielding Trade Relationship

Despite the intensifying diplomatic dispute, the trade relationship between Canada and India remains resilient. India, which is Canada’s 10th largest trading partner, has so far maintained a commitment to keeping trade channels open. In fact, a study by the Asia Pacific Foundation of Canada indicated that the earlier allegations made by Trudeau in October 2023 had minimal impact on trade. Analysts now question if this stability can hold amid worsening tensions, though trade experts believe that economic pragmatism will likely prevail.

Canada is the largest exporter of pulses, including lentils and peas, to India, a vital component of India’s food supply chain. Greg Cherewyk, President of Pulse Canada, expressed confidence in the continuity of this trade flow, emphasizing the need for affordable food products amidst inflation. “In a time of stubborn food price inflation and strong demand for pulse crops, we are confident that affordability and availability will continue to drive decision-making at a government level,” Cherewyk stated. As Canada’s agri-food industry seeks to diversify export markets, India remains an important partner due to its high demand for Canadian agricultural products, which include not only pulses but also grains and specialty crops.

Michael Harvey, Executive Director of the Canadian Agri-Food Trade Alliance, reinforced this positive outlook, noting, “India and Canada have great potential in their trading relationship, and CAFTA hopes we can work back to positive trade discussions.” Harvey’s optimism reflects the broader sentiment within Canada’s export community, which views trade as a stabilizing factor amid the diplomatic rift.

Diplomatic Stalemate and Potential Future Actions

Ottawa has not indicated immediate plans to escalate diplomatic or economic pressure on India, largely due to the unresolved nature of the Nijjar case. Vina Nadjibulla, Vice President of the Asia Pacific Foundation of Canada, suggests that Canada may hold off on further actions until additional evidence emerges. “If there are charges laid on individuals living in India at whatever level, then it would trigger an extradition process which could take years. And, of course, India is unlikely to cooperate,” she said.

This diplomatic stalemate could prolong, with both countries hesitant to escalate, given the potential ramifications for immigration and cybersecurity, areas that directly impact the people and economies of both nations. Analysts believe Ottawa’s approach remains cautious, possibly reflecting the government’s reluctance to disrupt a relationship that serves critical Canadian interests, from trade to multicultural ties.

The Role of Public Sentiment and Domestic Pressures

Back in Canada, the Sikh community remains concerned, as they await a more definitive government stance on the issue. The recent accusations against India’s Minister of Home Affairs Amit Shah have only intensified these anxieties. As one of the largest Indian diaspora communities, Sikhs in Canada play a significant role in the cultural and political fabric of the country, placing additional pressure on Trudeau’s government to address the matter with transparency and accountability.

Public sentiment in Canada has shown signs of increasing unease about foreign interference and espionage. As the government grapples with these concerns, calls for stronger measures to protect Canadian sovereignty have emerged from both the public and parliament members. Balancing national security with diplomatic relationships will be critical for Trudeau, particularly as Canada faces its own complex landscape of domestic and international challenges.

Looking Ahead: A Fragile Balance

As Canada navigates this turbulent phase with India, the situation underscores the complexities of balancing diplomatic relations with domestic priorities. While immigration delays and cybersecurity concerns may strain Canada’s resources and patience, trade relations continue to anchor the relationship, offering a semblance of stability amid the turmoil.

Experts anticipate that Canada will take a measured approach, cautiously addressing security concerns while maintaining economic stability. However, should further evidence or developments arise, this fragile balance may be tested, potentially altering the dynamics between two of the world’s largest democracies. As both nations watch carefully, the coming months may reveal whether the focus will shift toward reconciliation or if deeper divides will take root, reshaping the Canada-India relationship for years to come.

(Source:www.reuters.com)

Categories: Economy & Finance, Geopolitics, Regulations & Legal, Strategy